We’d spent most of the morning cooped up in the car, my husband and I, and our three children, with another sixty miles still to go. Our destination was my sister’s place in the northwestern corner of Illinois. The Cleary clan was assembling there to celebrate my parents’ fiftieth wedding anniversary. Clare, my oldest sister, owned a small farm with spacious accommodations, horses, haystacks, cats, dogs, two goats, a hen house, you name it, everything city kids could want.
An hour earlier, we’d parked near picnic tables outside a highway service station to have lunch: sandwiches, fruit and cookies brought from home, and ice-cold sodas purchased in the station’s mini-mart.
We’d cleaned up, tossed around a Frisbee while John made his phone calls, used the facilities, refueled, and climbed back into the car.
I usually relished the long stretches through farmland, preparing us for our eventual arrival like a spellbinding prologue. Peeks at grazing horses and cows, tractors, the smell of offal and ripening strawberries coming from both sides of the highway, the barns, some freshly painted, others weather-beaten, red, white, gray. The circle of buildings and gardens nestled far from the highway, the neat rows of crops, fences.
That day I couldn’t wait for the trip to end, to get lost in the gregarious Cleary clan and as far away as possible from my husband.
The children ignored the tension between John and me; they had their own squabbles to settle, of the stop it (poke), no, you stop it (harder poke) variety and John’s or my curt orders to cut it out were barely acknowledged. I may have been wrong about our eldest.
It was partly cloudy, windy and humid. We rode with the car windows down, air conditioning off, which thankfully induced drowsiness in the youngest members of our family. Timmy and Joanie, aged eight and five respectively, had stopped teasing each other and were fast asleep. Next to Joanie’s booster seat, sat our stalwart twelve-year-old, Brendan, quietly listening to his favorite tunes on his head phones. From my reading and chats with my sisters I guessed that Brendan had less than a year to go before his hormones turned him into a monster.
But I had bigger worries that particular afternoon.
“We should talk,” I ventured.
“Not before the next turn-off,” he grunted back. “Check the map. 290 should be coming up real soon.” We had missed the 290 cut off before, and today of all days neither of us wanted to prolong the drive one unnecessary moment longer.
As co-pilot, I picked up the map, creased to the familiar square of land we were crossing. “The cut-off is at least another five exits away. The children are asleep but you know that won’t last.” The bating tone in my voice didn’t help but I seemed to have lost control over it. This had become my manner with my husband of fourteen years on those rare occasions when we spoke in private. The wall that had risen between us in the last four months due to his withdrawal both infuriated and intimidated me. For months I had tried making him tell me what was wrong but nothing worked, he either stormed off or kept away, slept on the couch or on his side of the bed, making it clear he wasn’t interested. We had gone through silent periods before but none had lasted this long. It fell on me to get the job done, or else the weekend would be wrecked.
“Fine, but just you keep one eye on the map.” John’s determination to lick this missing-the-290-exit thing sounded more urgent than ever that day. Was he thinking this might be our last trip to the farm as a family? He changed lanes and smoothly passed another gargantuan eighteen-wheeler. He was a better driver than I, good with machines in general. Once he got ahead of it, he said, “You start.”
Okay.
I took a breath and began. “I want us both to agree to get through this weekend civilly.” I must have mentally rehearsed saying that line a hundred times in the last hour. It was a relief to get through it without pleading.
John peered over his glasses at me, frowning. “We already said we would.” How hollow his voice sounded. “What, you don’t trust me?”
“Should I?”
“Megan,” he snarled before directing his gaze back to the road. My frustration with the difficulty we had confronting each other, and trying to snatch a few moments of his divided attention while the children slept, while the car was zooming down the highway at sixty miles an hour, all but derailed me. Yet, the last thing I wanted to have happen was for our very private situation to become the talk of my family whom we would soon be joining. He had come home late again last night after I’d gone to bed and once the day started, we never had a moment to ourselves, hurrying breakfast, packing the car, locking up the house. I had no choice: now or never.
Joanie squirmed and coughed. Brendan, seasoned older brother and the recipient of her unintended kick, reached over and patted her thigh until she dozed off again, never once opening his eyes.
“Look, John.” I said and peeled my eyes away from the cozy scene in the back seat to face him, “they will catch on. Clare will, for sure. She thinks we are the golden couple, as hot for each other as on the day we met. She still lived at home back then, remember? It will kill her to find out we’re in trouble. Especially after Monica.”
So far, so good. Neither one of us had broached the subject of separation but only because we were just reaching the point where some action must be taken. (My baby sister Monica’s divorce was still fresh and cast a shadow on the family reunion. They had been married only eight months when it was discovered that her husband had another family living in Mexico. Unlike me, she had kept us Clearys apprised of each titillating revelation.)
Marriage counseling was out of the question as neither of us could face airing our problems in front of a third party. Both of us were shy, how would any intervention work? I flexed the fingers of my left hand and momentarily sunlight dazzled my diamond ring.
***
We met in high school. John was a transfer student my sophomore year. That was a tough year: my mother lost her last baby, a boy, and nearly died in childbirth, my father’s drinking kicked up several notches and led to hospitalization, a shoulder dislocation sidelined me from the tennis varsity team and my best friend Shirley moved away.
I was quiet by nature, the Cleary wallflower. Losing Shirley, my childhood confidant, at the start of that crucial school year, on top of all the other losses, turned me inward. Then after Christmas break, John simply appeared one day, loping down a hall in the opposite direction, lean, lanky, a complete albeit hunky stranger smiling down at me. I tried to look away, but then we both turned into the same classroom. “You first,” he said, still smiling while gallantly flinging out his arm. I gazed up at him, relieved that the boy of my dreams was three inches taller than me. Certain he could read my mind, I blushed. I hadn’t felt that sensation, well, ever. Like immediate trust paired with mature lust.
***
Now John checked the rearview mirror and the children. For whatever reason, that ordinary gesture at that specific moment touched me. Though the lack of words got in our way often, actions were telling. So, he still loved and cared for them, provided for Brendan’s braces and Joanie’s dance class. Brought Timmy home a treat every night after he got chicken pox. All morning long, he had pointed out things to the kids, played the license plate game, My Father Owns a Grocery Store, stopping when one of them needed to pee. What was I thinking, I must be deranged, there never was any doubt that John loved our children. It was me he no longer desired.
“Only if you tell her.”
I shook my head. “No, John, Clare will know. I guess being single, she lives through our marriages and our children.”
He let a half mile slip by before he commented.
“Maybe she’s better off.”
“Ha! You don’t know diddly.” A discussion-ending thrust if ever, delivered in a childish tone. Even before the words were out I knew I’d blown it.
***
It turned out that John was a junior and didn’t belong in that classroom that day. Years later he told me that when he first saw me, he wanted me, and for once his shyness did not interfere. He could think of no other option than to stick close by me until he learned my name and phone number.
We had much in common, and a thrilling physical attraction to each other. The one serious drawback was our mutual reticence. About all things sexual, but also money, family secrets, intimate feelings, even IQs. John wanted to know mine one afternoon as we headed to a basketball game. It didn’t mean much to me so I told him. He stopped, mid-step, and frowned. His, it so happened, was two points lower. I reminded him how notoriously inaccurate IQ tests were known to be, all the while thinking to myself, what’s the big deal? What were my choices, to lie, play dumb, tell him I didn’t know? Yes, I answered myself, in the future, lie, play dumb, claim ignorance—ha! Again, what’s the big deal?
John.
I kept a diary and excitedly wrote down my feelings. Who did John tell about his feelings for me? He spent more time at my house than we ever did at his.
He was an only child. His father was a bank auditor and his mother a tax attorney. Both worked long hours. He grew up lonely, he once told me, and wasn’t allowed to even have a pet because his mother wanted their various condos to be kept spotless and showable at all times. Also, he had been born with a speech impediment that added to his self-consciousness and only got corrected after he reached third grade. They moved frequently due to his parents’ successful careers and the multiplicity of bank merges. Friendships were short lived but John claimed that after we met, he stopped being lonely. All he wanted out of life was a family, a real home, and a lifetime to enjoy them.
Dating John was the most fun I’d even known. He was new to Chicago and we went everywhere, exploring. We explored each other, too. Our mistake was to lay claim to each other too quickly. I hadn’t dated much before we met. He had, that was evident. I found I was not as shy around him but not entirely candid, either. If, for example, I didn’t want to go out some nights due to cramps, I went anyway, and kicked myself later for not being able to tell him. Having no brothers, I might have looked to one or the other of my parents for guidance but their marriage was acrimonious—not the model I needed—until ten years ago when my father found sobriety. My sisters all had big mouths, I couldn’t trust them. So I kept many of my feelings to myself. Was I afraid that John would suddenly vanish like Shirley? Or was I in love?
My family liked him and welcomed him into our activities. John liked them as well, though he sometimes felt overwhelmed by all of us. But he hung in there, I could see he was making an effort and I appreciated it. Mother once commented that John was a lad of few words. Then she chortled and added, “While your father knows too many.” We each had our own friends but saw less of them and more of each other as time went on, though I was also glad for my reading club and the babysitting jobs I got. Chores at home kept me busy, too, or what I came to think of as my downtime from John.
One afternoon we were necking on the beach, totally involved, when he suddenly told me he loved me. He had never said it before. This satiated feeling came over me. I knew I needed to be alone for a while to take in the meaning of that moment, to let it float deep down inside of me and rest, like a rare pearl on the bottom of the lake. We were going out that night to a dance but when I got home, I didn’t want to see him again so soon. But then, how could I cancel after what he had just said? I couldn’t. I didn’t.
The end of his senior year might have been the end of us. He was heading off to college in a neighboring state. I actually looked forward to our impending separation, not that I wanted to date anyone else, rather so I could be alone, to think, rediscover life on my own, be celibate like some of my friends with older boyfriends, a “senior widow.” I wanted to know, for sure, that he was the one and I could hardly do that with him constantly underfoot. However, I could think of no tactful way to tell him.
And then he ended up changing his mind, and put off college a year so we could go together. He thought his surprise would make me happy. It didn’t make me happy, it frustrated me.
We began having disagreements, fights. We broke up twice that year. But we couldn’t stay mad for long. Loneliness and desire kept drawing us back to each other. There wasn’t anyone else I wanted to be with as much as I wanted to be with John.
His proposal startled me on an otherwise ordinary morning in January of our senior year of college. We were back home, still on winter break. He took me out to breakfast at the Pancake House across from our old high school.
“Megan,” he asked, taking my hand, after we placed our order. “Do you want me to get down on one knee?”
“What? Why would you do that?” I giggled. Had I dropped something on the floor, a napkin, a spoon? Sometimes John could be such a clown.
“Because I will. I will do anything for you.” He kept his eyes on my face. Puzzled, I scanned the booth, searching for a clue as to what he was talking about. Everything seemed to be in its appointed place. Meanwhile, he put a small box on the table between us and it finally dawned on me what was happening. He took my other shaking hand.
“I know I don’t always say things right or tell you how I feel but today I will. I’ve loved you from the moment we met six years ago today in a hallway in that building across the street. I have waited for you all my life. I’m only going to do this once, I mean, with only one girl, um, though it may take more than once to get the answer I hope for.” He chuckled to himself, quieted, and then asked, “Megan Alice Cleary, will you marry me?”
All the sounds of the restaurant receded. The sound of my heartbeat filled the vacuum.
The ring was not a diamond. I’d been adamant with him whenever we talked about the future that I did not want one. My ring, I discovered when he opened up the jewelry box, was made in Ireland. An emerald knot ring, like one I’d seen on a website long ago, so discrete and simple that tears of happiness spilled down my radiant face. He remembered. He cared. John was it. No more doubts.
***
I adjusted my seatbelt feeling totally miserable in the confining space of the front passenger seat. I wished I could undo my last remark and repair the damage I’d done. We were trying to have a discussion, or argument, talking at least, and then I had to go spoil the moment. I hid my face behind the map.
We were alone on the highway; we’d out driven the dirty truck hogs, hooray. My clothes were sticking to me. “Can we turn on some air?”
“Sure.” He hit buttons to close the windows and I started the air conditioning.
“It’s at least another thirty miles to the exit,” I reported. Marriage required these constant flips, from emotional precipices to the mundane.
“Right.”
***
John and I were married after graduation. Not in a church wedding but in a simple ceremony in the chapel at the college we both had attended. My parents had already footed the bills for three weddings, and besides, neither of us liked crowds. We liked quiet times being together. As though our intimacy was our secret.
He had always been a hard worker. After trying several different jobs, he went in with a buddy on a print shop franchise. I was a librarian at a nearby art school. Each of our jobs suited us. He later bought out his partner and opened a second shop. Within four years we had our home and we had Brendan.
Brendan opened us up. I mean, Brendan demanded we talk to him and to each other. He cried a lot and we had to wake each other up to feed him. John was an involved, committed father, and shared Brendan’s caretaking with me. When Brendan got whooping cough, our pediatrician marveled at our patient parenting.
Brendan engaged us with smiles and tricks. He loved best the times when we three were together and cried every morning when John left for work. At first, he seemed to share our secret. But as he got older, his curiosity about himself, us and the world developed normally. He expected us to make up silly stories on the spot, to answer any and all questions, sing lullabies, act goofy in front of his playmates. Brendan charmed us with his insatiable sociability and we relaxed with each other. John was over the moon with contentment and my prayers were full of gratitude.
It took longer to conceive Timmy. John grew anxious. Brendan was not going to grow up alone as he had. By then I was a fulltime mom, editing the art school’s marketing projects on my home computer. When Timmy was born, John’s parents died in a plane crash. On the same day. He had to leave me right away to attend to their funerals and affairs. He was gone a whole month and called every night while he was away. When I wasn’t there to take his call, he became angry. It annoyed and embarrassed me. I marked it down to mourning, homesickness, worries about his business, stresses at the other end. Alone with a new baby and a four-year-old, when the walls began to close in on me, I’d walk the children over to visit my sister who lived close by. If we stayed late, I texted him but he wouldn’t call me there. Too shy to call me at my sister’s house?
***
The air between us had chilled beyond the air conditioning’s range. Crazily I thought one of us had better get off the dime or else the children would all freeze to death. I switched off the air and opened my window.
It surely wasn’t going to be John. In the last four months he had clammed up so tightly that on any given day, aside from the children’s needs, we barely exchanged a dozen words. I thought work must be bothering him. We were managing even during the economic downturn but the rent on his print shops had gone up dramatically in the last year and had severely impinged on our savings. Though his parents had left him a bundle, we put that aside for college tuitions, one of the few times we arrived at a financial decision easily. But then, when he no longer wanted me sexually, I thought there must be another woman. I panicked for I couldn’t confront him.
The shyness problem again, this time, mine. It is diabolical. Shyness can trump happy sex, intimacy, money matters, decision making, good times, bad times, sickness, death, family life, life itself. It’s a brutal thorn in the side because suddenly you find yourself having to deal with other lives besides your own, having to be an example for them. And they in turn burst your world wide open to neighbors, teachers, after school activities, endless new situations. My eyes scanned the children. None of them were shy as far as we could tell. Brendan played guitar in a band and was well liked, Timmy made friends with everyone he met and Joanie loved to be cuddled by anyone. We’d have to watch that. We?
“Megan, do you know how much I need you?”
I swallowed hard and watched as we sped past another exit before I forced myself to say, “Then why won’t you—”
“Make love?” He said it so wistfully I felt my skin prickle. “With someone who thinks she could do better? Megan, that really hurt.”
“What are you talking about?”
“Come on, Megan. Phil Jacobs?”
His words shocked me to the core. Once, two years after we married, I’d had a brief fantasy about a man I worked with, Phil Jacobs, an instructor at the art school. He was divorced, balding and shorter than I, not nearly as good looking as John on his worst day, but open, gregarious, a people person, outrageous at times, earthy and sexy, with no ounce of shame or reticence in him. At home I was learning that life with John could often be work. I had to watch my moods and choose my words; at those times the guardedness wore me out. Whereas being in Phil’s easygoing company, our flirtation felt comfortable, natural. Admittedly, he turned me on, yet it was limited to work; we weren’t having an affair, we were only ever just good work friends. A harmless daydream. Until he got hired at Pratt and I never saw him again. The End.
“I haven’t thought about him in years. What does he have to do with—”
“Not true, Missy, not true. You wrote to Shirley about him not long ago.”
“You read my mail?” I gasped incredulously. Someone was honking loudly behind us.
“Eyes on the road,” I yelled and jerked my head toward my window where a sudden wind gust hit me full face.
My old friend Shirley and I had found each other again through Facebook. She lived in Oregon, widowed, two children, where she hosted a political talk radio show. I sent her a naughty birthday card and she responded, overjoyed, with one to me. We initiated a pen pal correspondence because of the time difference and endeavored to top each other’s cards.
John had said I thought I could do better.
What better?
Fourteen anniversaries. The boys. His enjoyment of my whacky family which had become his family. A home onto which he added the wrap around, screened-in front porch I’d always wanted. And in the midst of that havoc came Joanie.
I was raised in a family of girls and so the two boys brought me immeasurable joy. But my daughter, my Joanie, was the icing on the cake. Little Joanie with my grandmother’s dimples, John’s eyes, my sturdy body. Joanie, who already possessed a voice that would one day terrorize a Broadway stage. I reached back and gave her foot a gentle squeeze and then faced him.
“Explain. Exactly what did you read and when?”
“It was on the back of a card in a bunch of bills I mailed for you. The envelope you used was practically see-through. It was during one of those times we were fighting about money and you wrote her and said something like how much easier life might have been with a guy like Phil Jacobs. It broke my heart, Megan.”
“You just picked up the envelope and tried to read what was inside.” My throat felt dry while I blinked back tears.
“No, I was getting ready to put them in a mail slot. I always check to see if everything is stamped and I don’t know, the words leapt out at me. Your words.”
I shook my head harder and harder as I pictured how this whole pathetic thing got started.
“John, you’re so wrong. That letter was in the first place none of your business—”
“I know.”
“And in the second place, if that’s what I wrote, it was a momentary blip. Haven’t you ever had one? A day when you wanted to…? Okay, how about when we all got the flu last winter? Didn’t that make you want to, I don’t know, take off and get some fresh air in, say, Bora Bora? You wished you were still single then, ha! But wishing it and wanting it are two different things. God, John. I don’t even remember writing that. And all this time you thought… What about you? What have you been doing? Coming home at all hours without telling me where you are—”
“Work Megan, I was either at work or the gym and you could always reach me. And no, for your information, I have never wanted to be single again. I’ve been avoiding you, trying to figure this out. What had I done wrong? What were you planning? Was Shirley helping you? It nearly drove me crazy.”
“And you couldn’t ask me about it? We couldn’t talk about it?”
No, of course not. His lips tightened into a scowl. I looked away. Better to grow cold together, than to risk talking it out. The hell with that! I felt so angry, and violated, so shut out. Would we ever get beyond this?
Then the necessary flip back to being co-pilot. “There it is. The 290, see the sign?”
“Dad, pull over! I feel sick!”
***
John caught Brendan’s anxious face in the mirror, deftly slowed and stopped on a shoulder that seemed to appear at the very moment we needed one. He cut the ignition and we all scrambled out of the car. Brendan hadn’t gotten car sick in years. Over the back of our bent over but not yet sick son, John and I glared at each other.
“I love only you.” My voice caught as I said it.
“What?” The roar of traffic had blown my brave avowal to the four winds.
“Mommy loves Daddy,” screeched Joanie in a timbre no measly six lane highway could compete with.
“So there,” I shouted in the approximate volume of our five-year-old.
“Me, too,” John yelled back.
“Good,” I retorted only because some book I’d read on shyness touted having the last word.
“I’m okay,” mumbled Brendan as he stood up and grinned. “False alarm.”
We took our time getting back into the car. Relief flooded my body and soul. I’d been stumbling around in a desert and suddenly an oasis had appeared. I wanted to giggle, to yodel. Was I wrong to feel so good? It shouldn’t happen that fast, night to day, dark to light, foreboding to glee.
But why not? Hadn’t I gotten what I’d wished for? Hadn’t I begun the trip wanting with all my heart for the tension to end? I didn’t want a divorce. I didn’t want anyone else. I’d actually spoken up! I was inventing a new me on this summer journey that had spun doubt into hope. True, John’s explanation needed fleshing out; for now, I was grateful for the lightning-like lift in my spirits. It wasn’t just that the children needed to see us relaxed again, it was more. I listened to my body. That satiated feeling of years ago didn’t return and make me want to run and hide, further proof of my willingness to be back in the flow. I wanted to be by John’s side now through the uncharted repairs, the renewed love making, new conversations. And they would come.
“Daddy?” asked a fortunately clueless though right on cue Timmy. “Are we there yet?”
“Almost.” John’s eyes softened for the first time in months and crinkled in my direction. All it took was one look, that look, and I blushed a bright tomato red. I felt sixteen again.
“Next exit is 290.”
“Are we having fun yet?” quipped Brendan as a signal to us that he was over his embarrassment.
I will always wonder if Brendan had heard us. He might not have understood the meaning of our choppy sentences, but he might very well have guessed that we were in the midst of a serious though stupid, possibly fatal misunderstanding. I plan to ask him one day in the future when nothing much else is going on. And in the meantime, get professional help to conquer my shyness whether John wanted to or not.
He reached over and squeezed my left knee. “John,” I cried. That gesture always drove me wild but that wasn’t it. “Eyes on the road—oh—oh—oh! N-o-o-o!” We sailed right past the 290 exit. Again! John kept his hand firmly on my knee, a smile on his face. “Well, kids,” he addressed the rearview mirror, “if this isn’t fun, I don’t know what is.” He started to laugh, a merry chortle I’d missed as much as making love with him, and instantly I found myself joining in while the back seat contingent wholeheartedly concurred.
Shy people don’t generally like a cheering crowd. But sometimes, we do.
*****
Sheila M. Cronin is the author of The Gift Counselor, a novel endorsed by Publishers Weekly Indie Spotlight as “goodwill for adults.” Cronin’s stories have appeared in Woman’s World Magazine, Novellum, Spark, Spillwords, Guideposts and more. Please visit www.giftcounselorbook.com for more details.

